Papi's Taqueria In Old Lyme, CT: Authentic Mexican Flavors

Percival Roob 08 May 2025

Can the vibrant tastes of central Mexico truly transport you to another world, right here in the heart of Connecticut? Papi's Taqueria, nestled in Old Lyme, Connecticut, boldly answers that question with a resounding "Yes!"

For those seeking an authentic culinary journey, Papi's Taqueria, located in the charming town of Old Lyme, Connecticut, presents a unique proposition. This isn't just another Mexican restaurant; it's a carefully curated experience, a celebration of the flavors and traditions that have long defined the mountain regions of central Mexico. It's a place where the dedication to fresh ingredients and time-honored cooking methods promises an unforgettable meal.

At the helm of Papi's Taqueria are owners Kate and Luis Adrian, lovingly known as "Papi." Their combined experience of over two decades in the restaurant industry serves as the foundation for their establishment's success. Located at 19 Halls Road, the taqueria has quickly become a local favorite, offering a welcoming atmosphere and a menu that showcases the true essence of Mexican cuisine. The taqueria is conveniently positioned right off Route 95 at Exit 70, making it an accessible destination for both locals and travelers alike.

Papi's Taqueria has garnered a loyal following, reflected in their active online presence. Boasting over 1,160 likes and a lively community, the taqueria fosters a space for interaction and connection, solidifying its status as a beloved local gem. The restaurants commitment to quality is evident in their approach to preparation, using only the freshest ingredients in every dish. This dedication to quality ensures that each bite bursts with flavor and embodies the true spirit of Mexican cuisine. Takeout is also a popular choice due to limited seating within the establishment.

Beyond the culinary experience, Papi's has become a gathering place for the Old Lyme community. As a Mexican restaurant that is open seven days a week, it has quickly become a place to visit when you are craving something spicy. The restaurant offers a variety of menu options, including the steak fiesta burrito and rice pudding. The taqueria provides an excellent choice for a casual meal, with an accessible location and a focus on genuine Mexican flavors.

Papi's Taqueria's menu is a testament to culinary craftsmanship. Among the highly recommended dishes are the steak fiesta burrito and the creamy rice pudding, offering a delightful combination of textures and tastes. The short rib tacos and carne asada tacos are other popular choices that keep customers coming back for more. The plantains, a traditional side dish, add a touch of sweetness that beautifully balances the savory components of the meal.

The popularity of Papi's has led to a vibrant online presence, as well. Customers can easily view the menu for Papi's Taqueria and explore the available options through online platforms. Moreover, the convenience of online ordering further enhances the dining experience, allowing patrons to effortlessly place orders for delivery or pickup. This approach has helped to increase the appeal of the restaurant.

The Old Lyme community often gathers at the Old Lyme Shopping Center, and Papi's Taqueria is a popular destination in the area. For a quick bite, customers can step into the small and welcoming space. The restaurant has two tables and a bar counter that invites guests to eat and socialize. It is a place to go when you're craving authentic, flavorful Mexican food.

The taqueria's location within the Old Lyme Shopping Plaza ensures easy access and visibility. Additionally, Papi's Taqueria is committed to providing a culinary experience marked by fresh, high-quality ingredients. The restaurant offers a friendly and inviting atmosphere for diners to enjoy the flavors of Mexico. The taqueria is open seven days a week, making it a flexible and convenient option for locals.

The success of Papis Taqueria has also made it a point of interest for local news and events. In a recent incident, crews were called to the Old Lyme Shopping Center at 1:16 p.m., according to Old Lyme Fire Marshal David Roberge. Lyme and Old Saybrook fire departments also responded. According to Roberge, the driver of the Finkeldey Septic Service truck went into Papi's Taqueria for lunch before discovering the truck on fire. Such incidents highlight the restaurant's visibility within the community.

The heart of Papi's Taqueria lies in the authentic flavors and deep-rooted culinary traditions brought from the mountains of central Mexico. The dedication to fresh ingredients and the mastery of traditional cooking techniques are evident in every dish, offering a taste of Mexico in the heart of Connecticut. The restaurants commitment to freshness enhances the dining experience, allowing guests to savor the true essence of Mexican cuisine.

In essence, Papi's Taqueria offers more than just a meal; it delivers an immersive culinary journey. From its vibrant atmosphere to its carefully curated menu, Papi's Taqueria provides a memorable experience, enticing customers to return for another taste of authentic Mexican food in Old Lyme. For anyone seeking an outstanding Mexican meal, Papis is the place to be.

Attribute	Details
Restaurant Name	Papi's Taqueria
Owners	Kate and Luis Adrian ("Papi")
Cuisine	Mexican
Location	19 Halls Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371, USA
Key Features	Authentic flavors from central Mexico, Fresh ingredients, Fast service, Takeout option
Recommended Dishes	Steak Fiesta Burrito, Rice Pudding, Short Rib Tacos, Carne Asada Tacos, Plantains
Ambiance	Small, Simple, Welcoming
Seating	Limited (2 tables & bar counter)
Opening Hours	7 days a week
Online Presence	Active on social media, Online ordering available
Reviews	5.0 of 5 on Tripadvisor, Ranked #10 of 20 restaurants in East Lyme
Other Locations	163 Boston Post Rd, Old Lyme, CT (mentioned but may not be current)
Nearby Landmarks	Old Lyme Shopping Center, near Exit 70 off I-95
Community Impact	A gathering place for the Old Lyme community
In the News	Associated with incident at Old Lyme Shopping Center

Papi's Taqueria is more than just a restaurant; it is a celebration of flavors and a tribute to the authentic culinary traditions of central Mexico. The restaurant offers a friendly and welcoming atmosphere, making it an inviting destination for anyone seeking a delicious meal. With a menu that showcases the fresh ingredients and traditional cooking techniques, Papi's Taqueria is one of the best options for Mexican cuisine in Old Lyme.

The culinary team at Papis Taqueria goes to great lengths to ensure that every dish is prepared using only the freshest ingredients available. From the savory tacos to the sweet plantains, each item on the menu reflects a commitment to quality. The owners, Kate and Luis Adrian ("Papi"), bring their extensive experience to the table. Papi's Taqueria provides a unique and memorable dining experience for all guests.

The restaurant also offers online ordering and delivery, which is popular, in addition to takeout. The restaurants convenient location and dedicated staff provide a unique experience for both local residents and visitors to Old Lyme. For those looking to explore the flavors of central Mexico, Papi's Taqueria is a must-visit destination.